At Maine’s annual Fishermen’s Forum in Rockport Friday, a historic $600 million harvest season coincided with a slight increase in lobster landings and lingering concerns over potential changes to gear rules around protecting endangered right whales. But looming over the forum are major cutbacks in the quota of crucial herring bait fish — which could ripple across the industry.
Patrice McCarron is executive director of the Maine Lobstermen's Association (MLA). She is worried about the severity of herring restrictions imposed by the federal government after the species failed to reproduce in sustainable numbers last year.
"It's about as bad as we can imagine, but we don't yet know what it's going to translate to for the fishermen," McCaroon says.
McCarron says that Maine fishermen face a shortage of some 50-million pounds of bait in the coming season.
Fisherman are used to catching the traditional lobster baitfish in Maine’s coastal herring fishery all summer and into the fall, but McCarron says that will change under the new quotas.
"We're seeing an 84 percent reduction in that particular source of bait, so we'll have less than 5,000 metric tons, which will probably be caught in a week, in one week," she says.
In a recent survey, 82 percent of MLA's members said the bait shortage could lead to an economic crisis in the industry. McCarron says that fishermen in remote locations may have the hardest time, because alternative bait sources are hard to get to.
But she also says that she has faith in the creative solutions fishermen can cobble together. Stonington lobsterman Bob Williams, who's been hauling traps for more than six decades, is taking an “all-of-the-above approach.”
"I have a cooler, and we stock up on bait and go different places before the season starts,” Williams says. “A lot of times, get the pogies, the menhaden, frozen bait too, which is now rockfish, big popular bait."
McCarron predicts bait prices will skyrocket when the lobster season really gets going in the spring, and that's even if the menhaden, also known as pogies, return to local waters in force this summer, as they have the last three years.
That has fishermen and state officials looking for new sources, such as frozen menhaden from the Gulf of Mexico, some types of carp, or even mink hides, as long as the fur is completely removed.
Patrick Keliher, the commissioner of the State Department of Marine Resources, was peppered with questions about alternative bait. He says that to be certain an imported species does not pose a disease threat to native stock, state review processes can take time, sometimes months.
"It does take a long time,” Keliher says. “It's not great news but that's the news I got."
Keliher says that while the bait crisis is an imminent peril, federal action to protect the endangered north Atlantic right whale could exacerbate hardship for the industry. He is working with regulators in other states and at the federal level to find solutions that will preserve the lobster industry's viability. Those could include a requirement to reduce the number of rope endlines in the water by 40 percent, starting next year.
He adds, though, that lawsuits that environmental groups have filed against the federal government to force new whale protections are an unpredictable factor.
"The courts, they're the wild card,” Keliher says. “They could put something in place tomorrow. We're hoping they won't. We're hoping that they will give deference to the agencies to do the work they need to do.”
Lobsterman Addison Ames, who fishes 800 traps with his brother off Vinalhaven, says that between the bait crisis and potential new whale rules, he's beginning to think about retirement.
"Every notch they put in unfortunately, I'll say, the going one way or another, it's just another hard financial situation for us, and... it's not going to work," Ames says.
Both state and federal level regulators are expected to propose new gear rules by spring or early summer. In the meantime, the great bait hunt is on.
Originally published March 1, 2019 at 5:16 p.m. ET.